Quai D'Orsay No. 54

From €50.30
Six banded cigars laid out on burgundy marble in James J. Fox, Dublin shop.

Buying Guide

Choosing Your First Cigar

Learn how body and strength differ, what size tells you, and how to cut, light and store a cigar.

Read the Guide
Open boxes of Partagás Serie D No. 4 and Davidoff Winston Churchill The Late Hour cigars on the marble counter at James J. Fox Dublin.

How to Choose Between Cuban and New World Cigars?

Generally, a Cuban cigar means a cigar made in Cuba, using tobacco grown in designated Cuban regions throughout the cigar (meaning that wrapper, binder and filler are all Cuban). Here, the main appeal is Cuban tobacco’s regional character and established cigar-making traditions.

New World cigars is an umbrella term for non-Cuban cigars, particularly those from Nicaragua, the Dominican Republic and Honduras. These may use tobacco from one country or combine leaves from several countries. The result is a wider variety of tobacco origins, blending approaches and styles, compared to the Cuban offerings.

Neither designation is a blanket quality rating. When comparing, it's more practical to focus on flavour and the cigar's strength/body. For a gift, the recipient’s established preferences are the strongest guide. Someone who enjoys Cuban cigars may value that heritage; someone who explores different blends may care more about the flavour profile than the country it came from.

Browse Cuban Cigars
Three handmade cigars with different lengths and shapes, including Davidoff and Joya de Nicaragua Cuatro Cinco, arranged on a marble counter.

What Can The Cigar Size Tell You?

Cigar size gives you clues about smoking time, how it feels to hold, and how the blend expresses its flavour. It doesn’t reliably tell you strength or quality.

Size is usually written as length × ring gauge. For example, 5×50 means five inches long with a diameter of 50/64ths of an inch – which is about 20mm. Names such as Robusto and Churchill describe familiar formats, and can be a hint on how long and thick the cigar is, but their exact dimensions can vary between brands.

  • Length: At a similar thickness, a longer cigar generally lasts longer. Smoking pace, construction and humidity also affect duration.
  • Ring gauge / thickness: A wider cigar generally produces more smoke and tends to burn cooler. A slender cigar can feel warmer and present flavours differently.
  • Tobacco proportions: Thinner formats have more wrapper relative to filler, which can make the wrapper’s character more noticeable. Different sizes within one cigar line can therefore taste different.
Browse Cigar Samplers

Handmade Cigars FAQs

Helpful answers to common questions about handmade cigars, from choosing the right one to storage and delivery.

Does handmade always mean long filler?

No, although in practice, long filler is much more common in handmade cigars. It uses longer sections of leaf; short filler uses shorter pieces. Both can be made entirely by hand. Check the individual cigar’s construction details rather than treating “handmade” as a long-filler guarantee.

What is the difference between body and strength?

Body describes the weight and presence of the smoke’s flavour on the palate. Strength usually refers to nicotine impact. They can be described together, but they are not the same measure. Use the body shown on a listing as a guide and read its tasting notes too.

Strength is the cigar’s nicotine impact; body is its richness and fullness on the palate.

  • Strength: How much nicotine “punch” you perceive, usually rated mild to strong. A peppery flavour or harsh smoke doesn’t necessarily mean high strength.
  • Body: How substantial the smoke feels and tastes – its weight, mouthfeel, and depth of flavour – usually rated light to full. Think of the difference in mouthfeel between tea and cream.

A cigar can therefore be full-bodied but medium-strength: rich, dense and mouth-filling, with a moderate nicotine impact. The terms are sometimes used interchangeably in marketing, so descriptions aren’t always consistent between brands.

Does a dark wrapper mean a stronger cigar?

Not necessarily. Wrapper colour does not tell you the strength of the filler blend. The wrapper contributes to the cigar, but a dark appearance alone cannot establish how strong it will feel. Check the blend and the stated body instead.

Which handmade cigar should I choose first?

Begin with a body and format that suit your preference and the how much time you'll have to enjoy it – larger cigars can easily take over an hour to work through.

As a general guide for beginners, we suggest starting with a smaller and milder cigar. Check out our blog: "Best Cigars for Beginners: A Complete Guide To Your First Smoke".

Can I buy a single cigar instead of a box?

Most of our handmade cigar listings offer a single-cigar option alongside pack or box options; the choices vary by product. Check the quantity selector on the individual listing when ordering.

What is the difference between a cigar sampler and a gift set?

Our cigar selections have a sampler version containing the cigars and a gift-set version that adds a cutter and jet lighter in a presentation box. Check each selection’s current contents and version before ordering; the cigars included differ between selections.

See our current cigar sampler and gift set selections here: Cigar Samplers & Gift Sets

How should I store cigars after delivery?

After delivery, your cigars should ideally be placed in a properly seasoned humidor to rest, maintaining a steady relative humidity of around 65–70%. Keep it somewhere cool, away from direct sunlight, radiators and sudden temperature changes.

If you don’t yet have a humidor, a well-sealed cigar storage bag with a suitable humidity-control pack provides a practical temporary option. If your cigars arrive in this type of packaging, keep it sealed between uses; an ordinary cigar box alone won’t maintain the humidity they need. Another improvised option could be a food-grade airtight container, ideally with a humidity pack as well.

Can I order for delivery or collect in Dublin?

We offer delivery and Click & Collect from 119 Grafton Street, Dublin. Check the shipping information for current services and conditions, particularly if ordering from outside Ireland.